Not so Happy Happy Happy….my thoughts on Phil Robertson

Although you may not know it, I am a huge Duck Dynasty fan. My family thinks that it is hysterical that I like this show so much.  Yet one of my favorite things to do to unwind after a day at work or a hard homework session is laugh and learn with the cast of Duck Dynasty.  Our family went to the set of the show over the summer vacation, and my little sister Olivia has worn her shirt that she purchased there into the ground.

So, it should not surprise you that A&E’s decision to “suspend” Phil Robertson from their show due to his comments concerning homosexuality has gotten me pretty upset.  If you haven’t heard about this so called controversy, let me explain.  Phil, the head of the Robertson family, was interviewed by GQ for their January 2014 issue.  In the interview, he touched on quite a bit of subjects.  He also offered some comments concerning the subject of homosexuality.  He had some graphic content, but basically condemned the practice of sexual relations with someone of the same gender.  He also made a point to show the slippery slope that sin can have, saying,

“Start with homosexual behavior, and just morph out from there.  Bestiality, sleeping with this woman and that woman and that woman and those men.”

The most resounding part of the article, however, was when he provided a thought from Corinthians:

     “Don’t be deceived.  Neither the adulterers, the idolaters,
       the male prostitutes, the homosexual offenders, the greedy,
       the drunkards, the slanderers, the swindlers – they won’t    
       inherit the kingdom of God.  Don’t deceive yourself.”

Let’s really look at this paraphrased Bible verse.  This is not saying:

     “Don’t be deceived.  Neither the adulterers, the idolaters,    
       the male prostitutes, ESPECIALLY the homosexual

No – in fact, it’s right up there with the drunkards! Christ wasn’t singling anyone out in their sin.  SIN doesn’t get into Heaven.  It doesn’t matter what sin, it’s not getting past the gates of Heaven.  So if you constantly lie, do not think you are any better than a person acting out on homosexual tendencies.  Without God’s grace and contrition on your part, Heaven isn’t going to be something for either of you to enjoy.

As I’ve stated before – Christians do not hate gays.  They don’t enjoy seeing them hurt or abused, or living in sin when Christ offers freedom from sin and addictions in every shape or form.  The fact that Wilson Cruz, who is a spokesperson for GLAAD said the following proves that he knows nothing about true Christianity:

     “Phil and his family claim to be Christian, but Phil’s lies  
       about an entire community fly in the face of what
       true Christians believe.”  

Christianity’s statement on this issue – a belief that should not only be verbally provided but LIVED is that people do not go to hell because they are “gay” or “straight.”  More importantly, having sexual feelings towards someone of the same gender isn’t a sin.  But, acting out on those feelings with full knowledge of the weight of that sin is a mortal sin.  (BTW, so is having sexual feelings towards someone of the opposite gender and then acting out on those feelings outside of marriage with full knowledge of the mortal sin effect.)

People struggle.  Everyone has their cross. Mine is my temper and quick snarky remarks.  Do you think that’s going to be welcome in Heaven?  Nope.  Although Saint Jerome could sure have at it. So if people struggle with homosexual tendencies,

The Catechism does a beautiful job of explaining the Church’s stance on the subject of homosexuality:

     “The number of men and women who have deep seated
       homosexual tendencies is not negligible.  This inclination,
       which is objectively disordered, constitutes for most of them
       a trial.  They must be accepted with respect, compassion,
       and sensitivity….homosexual persons are called to

Translation?  There most definitely are people who struggle with homosexual tendencies.  And their struggle isn’t fake, so it should be treated with respect and love.  As children of God they should be accepted into a community with love (NOT their sin, THE PERSON.)  More over, they are called to chastity

Yet not just homosexual people are called to chastity.  All of God’s children are called to chastity.  

So, in regards to Phil Robertson’s comments and consequent hiatus from the show, I think his comments couldn’t have come at a better time.  I’ll close by sharing my Dad’s thoughts on the subject:

“John the Baptist was a manly man out in the wilderness preaching repent and come to God…as does Phil.

John the Baptist made people be curious about the message…as does Phil.

John the Baptist told Herod the truth about his sinfulness…as does Phil.

John the Baptist paid with his head…Phil was suspended from the show.

Jesus gives me my hope..Phil is just one example of Godly men standing in the breach of the city wall with evil attempting to come into the city.  God is calling all of us to stand in the breach.  Is your faith making people uncomfortable? Every pastor and priest needs to be standing in the breach and preaching the truth…whatever that may cost.”

God bless!

Chloe M. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s